When I was a young student, my teacher insisted I first learn each hand separately and only then play both hands together. I found this more than a little frustrating. I always felt I had to start all over again when I put my hands together; all of the proceeding work with hands separate was a waste. Eventually in a pique of rebelliousness I quit playing with my hands separately, except for when I was asked to do so in a lesson.
I have often wondered about where the notion of learning each hand separately originated. I can picture a scenario like this: JS Bach tells CPE Bach he should pay extra attention to the right hand passage he continuously mis-plays. CPE tells his student he should play the right hand a couple times to fix a problem. Beethoven then tells his student Czerny that his right hand is very sloppy and he needs to fix it before the next lesson or he will use the ruler. Finally Czerny tells everybody to practice each hand separately.
So let’s break the cycle. The piano is a two handed instrument requiring a constant partnership between the hands. A good sight reader doesn’t run through each hand before playing, he just plays both hands immediately.
Now before you completely write me off as a crank, I will allow brief hands separate work but only in the interest of clarification of technical details and fingering. After that put them together!
I have found two meanings for this rule, one practical and one life changing.
First the practical. Left to our own devises we will start our work at the beginning and work our way to the end. Cognitive science explains some of the phenomenon we experience with this approach. The two primary challenges we encounter involve issues of interference and recency. Interference occurs when new or old material will block or interfere with recall. Sometimes the new material is similar enough to the old material as to create a conflicted memory. (This happens a lot in music!) Recency is the principle that we remember the most recent event better than older events. If we start at the beginning and play to the end we will remember the beginning well because it is the beginning and had our clearest focus; and the end almost as well because it is recent. But the middle is some kind of vague muddle of notes we know we played but have no idea what we did.
If you begin at the end and work backwards toward the beginning; first leaning the last measure and then the next to last measure, playing both; and then adding another measure and so on; each measure has a chance to be the beginning. Your retention of the middle is greatly enhanced.
A few years ago, while reviewing my repertory list I realized that I had learned about 1/3 of Beethoven’s piano sonatas. Into my silly head popped this notion that it would be a good thing to learn and play them all as preludes and postludes at my church. It took several years to complete this project of playing the entire set of sonatas sequentially. When I finally completed the project and had a chance to look back on my work and began to do it again, I had a profound sense of what the poet T. S. Elliot meant by:
“We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.”
I say this as a lover of speed. I have worn out many metronomes in my life, not from throwing them out of frustration, but from use. I work meticulously to achieve my ambitious tempo goals and then exceed them by 10% to ensure ease. Yet all too often I get caught up on faster and forget there is more to music than speed. Many times there is a lot less music with more speed. Finding the balance between a tempo with brings life and one which crushes music is a constant struggle.
The only way to eat an elephant is also the only way you can learn a 30 minute concerto: one bite at a time, any more and you will choke on it.
Music is a foreign language and it has many dialects. There is vocabulary, grammar and syntax, meaning and context. As with any language, the better you understand all of its subtleties, the better you can express yourself in that language.
If you compare the harmonic language of Bela Bartok with Serge Rachmaninov’s you can see a significant difference in their use of dissonance even though they lived at the same time. The most stringent dissonances in Rachmaninov’s music would be almost consonant in Bartok’s music.
Understanding the syntax of music allows for a quicker and more accurate recognition of patterns and structure. Without this understanding everything is meaningless randomness which happens to sound nice. While French may be pleasing to listen to as a harmonious language, I have no idea of the meaning behind those sounds so my appreciation and understanding is severely limited.
Your subconscious mind records your actions without judgment. It doesn’t know you missed the F# again, and AGAIN! Every mistake becomes part of your learning. That repeated mistake will to take on a life of its own, like a monster from a horror flick; it never dies and has a hundred lives to torment you with.
Slow, careful practice is the only route to success, to speed up before you have cleaned up will simply give you a fast mess.
There is no time like the present to be perfect!
Back in my student days it was a cumbersome or nearly impossible to listen to different interpretations of a work one right after the other. The school library may have a few duplicate recordings but not many. Today you can hear dozens of different renditions on uTube of just about anything. Try this exercise: Listen to the first minute of a work played by four or five different musicians. Do it again and this time observe the different details of tempo, dynamics, articulation. Observe how the music changes as these details are changed. How does tempo change the character of the melody? How does the articulation change your focus of attention? Is there a counter melody somewhere in the accompaniment? How does this affect the texture? A great piece of music cannot be played fully all at once; it contains more material than can be brought out in a single performance. Learning to listen below the surface can open a whole new horizon of understanding.
We have all been guilty of trying to cram for a test, or writing a paper the night before it is due. What is the usual outcome? Not good! The human mind needs time to fully absorb new information, neurological pathways take time to form and become stable. Part of becoming a professional musician is the ability to absorb and perform music in as short of a time as possible. However this ability is really a reflection of solid earlier study which created a broad familiarity with a particular type of music. Taking time to carefully learn something new, giving yourself time to revisit the material many times over many days or months is the surest way to fully absorb and integrate this new material.
One of my favorite rules is: Keep It Simple Stupid! I am often guilty of analyzing a passage or even a written performance instruction to death.
This also reminds us that simplicity is the beginning of expression. We should project the central idea or line and then all else becomes secondary. Playing too many important things makes for a cacophonous mess, or is simply a case of lazy playing. Think about the single most important element and make sure that is clear first.
Many editors also will suggest elaborate fingering schemes which add unnecessary layers of difficulty to otherwise simple passages. I am not nearly smart enough to remember all of this fancy finger dancing so I always choose simple, easy to remember fingering patterns.
Like me on Facebook
- Thank-you for your very kind works. Yes, your daughter will...July 11, 2022 - 11:33 am by Andrew
- Thank you for this post, Andrew. My daughter is due to...June 26, 2022 - 6:52 am by Mrs GC
- The last I heard, Linda is still there! I am not sure what...January 14, 2022 - 8:36 am by Andrew
- My wife and I remember with fondness our years in Bad Axe,...January 7, 2022 - 7:11 am by Dively
- About this Blog
- Complete List of Playlists
- Complete Recording List Links
- Hymn History Article List
- Hymn Recording List A
- Hymn Recording List B – C
- Hymn Recording List D – G
- Hymn Recording List H
- Hymn Recording List I
- Hymn Recording List J – L
- Hymn Recording List M -N
- Hymn Recording List O
- Hymn Recording List P – S
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name A
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name B
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name C – D
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name E – F
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name G – H
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name I – L
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name M – N
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name O – R
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name S
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name T – U
- Hymn Recording List Sorted by Tune Name V – Z
- Hymn Recording List T
- Hymn Recording List U – Z
- Resource Suggestions – Educational Material for Children
- Resource Suggestions – Gift Ideas
- Resource Suggestions – Hymnals
- Resource Suggestions – Hymns and Their Histories
- Resource Suggestions – Learning to Play Hymns
- Resource Suggestions – Solo Classical Piano Music
- Resource Suggestions, Master List
- Resource Suggestions: Musician Biographies
- Resource Suggestions: Piano Lamps by Koncept
- Solo Piano Music
- The Hymns of Anne Steele
- The Hymns of Augustus Toplady
- The Hymns of Charles Wesley
- The Hymns of Fanny Crosby
- The Hymns of Frances Ridley Havergal
- The Hymns of Horatius Bonar
- The Hymns of Isaac Watts
- The Hymns of James Montgomery
- The Hymns of Jared Bernotski
- The Hymns of Joachim Neander
- The Hymns of John Bacchus Dykes
- The Hymns of John Newton
- The Hymns of Linda Bonney Olin
- The Hymns of Lowell Mason
- The Hymns of Ruth A Coberly
- The Hymns of Thomas Kelly
- The Hymns of William Cowper
- YouTube Gallery